we got out in the east wind and did the same, similar everything, waves, depth, lures etc.
we're pretty new to lake ontario, but we're pretty good on lake erie, anyways... we got home and i wanted to do the same, but i had to work early the next morning
locate the fish on sonar or fish the thermocline (temp unit) 42-43-50* f
or cover the water column and adjust accordingly
try different speeds 1.8-3.5 mph, with gps, also check rods for lure action
pay attention to tackle
good luck