I love catching pike but dont really want to continue trying to catch big pike. All i want to know is what finger lake (or river, pond, something by the fingers etc.) have the best fishing for hammerhandles? I say hammerhandles because many times when you get into pike less than a foot and a half long you will get into groups of them, and i like quantity over quality and have had little success on sodus bay (all though i never go for them there). What finger lake has the best pike fishing and where?