I'm new to the forum and very new to trolling! I'm in need of help.
I have spent the past 20 years fly fishing and spin fishing for trout in the streams around Rochester (Mainly the Oatka). A few years ago I built a small wooden skiff that I mostly take out on ponds and small bodies of water.
2 years ago I "Discovered" Hemlock lake and fell in love. I started out fishing for panfish, perch and bass with the occasional Pike for good measure. After my first trip I found out there Lakers, browns and Salmon in there! I did my research and I decided to try trolling with a dipsy diver and spoon. I have a 30lb trust electric trolling motor so I bought a low end okuma trolling rod with a line counter reel and gave it a shot. I probably spent more time adjusting the diver and adjusting speed then fishing. The diver tripped one time that I thought was a strike but no hookup. I tried changing speed and direction and lures but I really only kind of know what I'm doing. It's all so new to me.
I met a guy at the north end launch as I was pulling back in and he was fishing lead core without a diver and had caught a nice salmon. Soooo like any skunked and depressed fisherman I went out and bought another pole and fitted it with a 10 color lead core with 30# backing and #20 mono leader. The next time I was out I ran the diver on one side and the lead right down the chute. After a hour or so I had a hit on my diver rod on a spoon. I was very excited to finally have a fish on but surprised when I netted a 19" smallmouth. The next trip was the same. A few tripped divers and possible bumps on my lead core. No trout but a very nice Smallmouth. The next TWO trips had no hookups and maybe one strike.
So lots of trips and no fish and I am at a loss. I have run a flasher fly setup. A dodger and spoon. a bare spoon. This is getting to be ridiculous and I'm ready to throw in the towel.
I am thinking about torturing myself with a trip on Saturday morning as long as the wind isn't blowing hard. Just wondering if any of you much more experienced fisherman can give me any advice or thoughts on what I'm doing wrong? Or advice on a rig or setup that has worked for you there? Also I've never fished hemlock in the spring, only summer and fall. Should I target a specific depth? Thanks in advance for your help!
-Steve