Jump to content

bandrus1

Members
  • Posts

    3,344
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by bandrus1

  1. 46 minutes ago, Missdemeanor said:

    If I'm duck hunting and I shoot my two redheads, can I legally then shoot my buddy' s two? Nope...... So to go by the letter of the law, once you catch your limit that's it... And I don't stay out on schools of fish sore lipping them or tossing back fish that might not make it . Is it legal? Yes... But in my eyes it's unethical if the fish are not going to make it... Such as summer Steelhead.... A limit is a limit and we are done... That's the law....period!

     


    Sent from my VS996 using Lake Ontario United mobile app
     

     

    Well I mean it's not the law. You can legally continue to fish with a limit by law

     

    Anyway back to topic

     

    If still like to be convinced that this law will actually impact lake guys due to limiting creel limits or impact trib guys increasing return rates. I have yet to see any evidence 

  2. 6 minutes ago, salmonboy41 said:

    If the rule doesn't effect anyone as you say why reduce the limit for steelhead from 3 to 2? If it doesn't affect anyone then it will not increase the numbers of steelhead which is the rational for the proposed change. So all this would do if you are correct is just create animosity between lake and trib anglers and open the door for more regulations. Makes one think doesn't it.

    I'm not saying it makes sense and I believe it is simply lip service but none the less I don't think it will impact people one way or another

     

    If someone has the raw creel survey data let's see the numbers

  3. 48 minutes ago, GAMBLER said:

    You can not take the captain and mates limit.  By law, if I am fishing with my buddy and I limit out, I technically can not fill the rest of his limit.  I had this conversation with an ECO on the ice. 

    I guess I didn't think of the taking, only the possessing part. It still isn't enforceable regardless

  4. 1 hour ago, Missdemeanor said:

    Keeping a Captain and Mate's limit is Illegal

     


    Sent from my VS996 using Lake Ontario United mobile app
     

     

     

    I have never seen this before. I'd like to read that regulation

     

    Edit it is not illegal

     

    "Which takes us to the main point of the blog’s title. With a push to make things more restrictive as far as creel limits in Lake Ontario, should we also be looking at a law or regulation that does not allow captains and/or mates to keep their limits, too? Currently, it’s a gray area. If they have a fishing license, they are entitled to their own limit of fish."

     

    https://www.outdoornews.com/2019/02/11/in-the-wake-of-new-regs-proposals-is-it-time-to-restrict-captain-and-mate-limits-on-charters/

  5. 2 hours ago, Fat Trout said:

    Whos arguing.  I was only replying to your comment that you were still waiting for pictures of limits (or near limits) of steelhead.  Limits happen.  If you target it happens....some places more than others.  If you want your limit take it.   Don't act like it never happens.    

    We have pages and pages of people arguing about it. And like admitted, you couldn't produce a picture of a whole limit. This should really be the end of the argument is that on the whole, it doesn't matter if the limit changes from 3 to 2 it will impact probably .005 percent of all the trips on Lake Ontario and you could probably even circumvent it if you really want to by keeping the Captain's and mate's limit on charters if you insisted

     

  6. 7 minutes ago, Fat Trout said:

    Well perhaps in this case since there are 5 people and a brown.

     

    image.thumb.png.717206dc730b285a50c3f65b00f2303c.png

    So we are arguing that their day would be ruined because they could only keep 10 steelhead not 15?

     

     

    That wouldn't even be a legal limit of steelhead under the proposed regulation.

     

    Again after all this debate I'm sticking by that this will have 0 impact on lake fishing or tribs because people hardly ever limit out on steelhead on the lake anyway

     

  7. Just a tip I have found

     

    I take a disposable heater (similar to hard warmers). They make them as body warmers with a sticky side, and I stick about 5 inches below my bellybutton on my underwear.

     

    You would be amazed how warm your feet stay if the blood is warmed up before it goes down your legs. I can stand in crotch deep water all day in winter with breathable waders

    • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...