There are bigger fish in Cayuga than Keyuka by 5 inch average. And the Keyuka fish are getting thinner, lighter built. had to find there also. I would recommend Deans cove or long point depending which side of the lake you are on. We fish Keyuka a lot just because our boat is so small, a 14 utility. Also this time of year trollers out do us st of the time, I just like to feel that express train clobber my jig with the rod in my hand.....jk