I agree with Pete. If it were me and I had the time to train a dog, I would go with another option for waterfowl. Personally, and I know I am asking for it by all the lab owners, I would forget about the frisbee and tennis ball chasers. A.K.A Labs and buy a hardcore waterfowl dog. A cheasapeake Bay retriever. Put your guns down boys, just kidding. I have hunted over great labs and chessies. One thing you dont need to train a Chessie is to retrieve waterfowl. You shoot one they go get it. The hard part is training them to be steady at the shot, and to bring it to hand. They are a stubborn breed and are tough as nails. I hunt late season ducks on Cayuga lake and I have never yet seen a lab that would willingly get into that really cold water on a real nasty day. A Chessie doesnt even think twice about it. Both dogs are very protective in terms of gaurding your home and family. A Chessie was bread to guard fishing shacks and can be very agressive towards a stranger. Labs will get along with other dogs easier than a Chessie also. Just some things to consider. If you go with a lab, or a Chessie just be sure it comes from good HUNTING lines. Many of the labs have a lot of "hunt" bred out of them from those who dont use them for hunting. I hate to think of the percentage of Labs that never have and never will retrieve a duck or goose because their owners dont hunt. I know there are Chessies that dont hunt also. A Chessies nose is incredible when it comes to waterfowl. Dont crucify me lab owners!