Andy, I still shoot a Briley Light Modified with 3 inch # 2 drylocks or kents and they work for me over decoying and pass shooting ducks. Brought down plenty of skycarp as well. I have tried a couple other tubes and wasnt convinced they worked any better with steel. I would try another tube if someone convinced me it was worth it. I like the remington supersonics but not worth the extra cost to me. I know I shoot along side of other guys shooting the high dollar stuff and they arent shooting any better than me. We still have to get together for a goose or duck hunt Andy.