Jump to content

GAMBLER

Professional
  • Posts

    9,951
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by GAMBLER

  1. If I were to shoot a deer on a farm for a nuisance tag tomorrow, would that count as my doe harvest to get my second buck tag?
  2. If Irondequoit Creek is a possible trib for Atlantic natural reproduction, why can't the DEC get Atlantic eggs and contract out the PowderMill Hatchery to raise the Atlantics. This would give the Atlantics a better chance of imprinting on the creek. This would increase the number of fish returning to a more fertile water.
  3. To raise Atlantics by dumping them in a pen in the lake only to release them to go wherever they want, isn't a good restoration strategy. What would they eat? How would you feed them?
  4. I was looking at the Daiwa Tanacoms. They are pricy but it might actually get my guys to reel in coppers more often!
  5. Last summer or the summer before there was a big influx of Pinks caught on Erie. Pete Alex caught a bunch throughout the season. He even had multiple fish in a couple of trips. Cool to see. I saw a photo of a pink from the Salmon River last fall too.
  6. I have three used but in decent shape Daiwa 400H reels and 1 Penn Senator reels for sale. $15.00 each or all four for $40.00. Will ship to the lower 48 at buyers expense.
  7. This was when VHS reared its head. The creel limit was 5 and it stayed 5 even though the bass population tanked. Like you, I have seen the rebound which is great to see. My buddy has been catching smallmouth of all sizes off his breakwall on Wautoma the past couple of years.
  8. Dave, Focusing on a sport fishery is putting the cart before the horse. Get the program producing wild fish by stocking tribs that make sense to get more out of the effort and then focus on the Sport fishery. If the stocking of Atlantics is for restoring the population, the priorities of the project are not right IMO. This reminds me of a state of the lake meeting years ago after the smallmouth bass population took a dive. I asked Steve Lapan why the creel limit is still 5 when the population is way down. His answer was "the bass tournament community doesn't want it reduced".
  9. I just can't believe the amount of people losing their minds over something so dumb. It will not change your life. Worry about something important. Life is short, go fishing......
  10. I'll say it again. With alewife as the dominant food source, it's going to be more of the same old issues (this is my number one issue with the Atlantic program). The scientists know this, yet we continue to pump resources and money into the project. Stock them in the best tributaries, fewer tributaries and move on. I would feel the same way with lakers and sturgeon. If the food they were eating in the lake was causing adult mortality and their populations weren't thriving, it's time to move the resources somewhere else in the lake that is more useful. Trying to get lakers and Atlantics to naturally reproduce in huge numbers will take decades of evolving in both species. Stream and spawning rehab projects are great, but Thiamine deficiency is a huge issue and isn't going away anytime soon. Dumping Atlantics in Oak Orchard and Sandy where they have zero percent chance of spawning successfully AND the offspring surviving is ridiculous (this is the other big issue with me on the Atlantic program). Stock them where they have the greatest chance. We stock kings in bigger numbers to increase survival. We spread out the small amount of Atlantics to a couple sites when you could find fewer sites that are more apt to support natural reproduction and SURVIVAL of the offspring. Manage the Atlantics as a tributary species like steelhead. Stock them in tribs that give them the best chances. Make those tributaries the destination tribs for Atlantic salmon. Worry about what is best for restoring Atlantic populations (if that is what this program is truly about) before worrying about a sport fishery for them (like the sturgeon). Stock them in fewer sites giving them better survival in numbers (like they did with the kings when they dropped a couple pen rearing sites). This summer, I participated in the King DNA study on the lake. We also had sampling containers for Atlantics. I was able to sample the only Atlantic we caught this summer. It was the smallest Atlantic I have ever caught on Lake Ontario in 42 years of fishing the lake. It was sampled and released and swam away strong. It is great to see the DEC leaning on Lake and Trib guys to gain data. Over the years, the resource was there and they didn't take advantage of it.
  11. 12,700 fish in that year. Let’s not forget the Canadian stockings, and multiple year classes. Atlantics should spawn more than once in their life cycle. The tribs should have way higher numbers than they do for the numbers stocked and multiple years classes of Atlantics. Atlantics are stocked in a handful of tribs on the south shore. If you take your 12,700 survivor number, divide it by the 4 or 5 tribs the stock, we should see way more Atlantics in the tribs.
  12. Dave, I have nothing against Atlantic salmon. They are a cool species and another species to catch. What I’m against is throwing money at a program that is doomed to succeed due to an alewife diet. I look at the Atlantic program like my retirement. I am not for pumping money and resources into a program with such low yields. If the food source in Lake Ontario didn’t cause adult mortality and natural reproduction issues, put more effort into the program. When you can’t target a species stocked with regularity (on both trib and lake), the juice isn’t worth the squeeze. I would love to see the numbers shocked in Sandy. They were shocking last fall and the guys that talked with the shocking crew said numbers were not good.
  13. Another shoot from the hip comment. A couple more years of over 100,000 Atlantics stocked. I emailed Chris Legaurd to get the actual numbers stocked back to 1983.
  14. Dave and Tom, In 1983 they stocked roughly 200,000 Atlantics in NY waters of Lake Ontario. Clearly not the first time they ever went over 100,000. Is Tom 100% right? I added a receipt for my shoot from the hip comment below. I’ll dig up yearly numbers when I have a chance. You wouldn’t have to move your boat to Pulaski to salmon fish Lake Ontario. Most know the majority of the salmon migrate from West to East as the season progresses. Most of the kings are imprinted on the Salmon River and return there as it is now. How can you not know this Dave?
  15. So this site is now lakeamericaunited.com?
  16. Dave, Sorry but your stocking numbers are false. According to the DEC website, the target is 200,000 Atlantics stocked. In 2025 they stocked 192,500 Atlantics. Here is the breakdown: South Sandy Creek 40,000 @5.5” south Sandy Creek 10.320 @7.0” Salmon River 30,000 @ 6.0” Salmon River 20,600 @6.5” Salmon River 20,630 &7.0” Sandy Creek 40,000 @5.5” Sandy Creek 10,320 @7.0” Oak Orchard 20,630 @6.5” Just imagine how well kings would survive if we kept them in the hatchery for a year. The sturgeon program is very successful. Numbers are climbing, they are living to adulthood and natural reproduction is up.
  17. Thiamine treatments are not done on natural reproduction fish..........Aren't most of the kings roaming Lake Ontario wild now? Hatchery fish are treated so they can maximize the survival rate of the limited eggs they take. With the number of Atlantics stocked, we should see decent returns but we don't!!! One of us understands that adult mortality in Atlantics is real and causes huge issues with the population. Compare the number of Atlantics (600,000 lake wide (some years Ontario stocked 625,000 alone making that number 825,000) stocked to the number of coho stocked (625,000). Compare catch rates of both species and return rates of each species. Coho blow Atlantics out of the water in both categories. Coho returns are awesome in the Salmon River and it's only one year class returning to spawn. Atlantics are stocked in big numbers in the Credit River and only handful return. There should be big returns seeing that Atlantics should spawn multiple times in their life cycle. The fin damage on Atlantics has been documented and is caused from crowded federal hatchery raceways.
  18. An all orange 8" echip with a Green Crinkle Atommik has been a staple for stagers for years.
  19. Les, Yes some survive but we call them unicorns for a reason. IT is definitely a stocked fish. The messed up dorsal fin is a prime example of a crappy product the hatcheries put out.
  20. Tom, Multiple year classes of Atlantics should be returning to the tribs. Look into the numbers stocked on the North shore and the dismal returns of less than 30 fish every year. Give it up already. This dead horse is pounded into the ground already. By the way, how many naturally reproduced kings in the Garnaska and Salmon Rivers treated for the thiamine issue........ Natural reproduction in kings is way up even though thaimine deficiency is an issue.
  21. Should be established is the key here.. Multiple year classes should be returning unlike kings and coho. A handful of fish is horrible. If I was dumping money into my retirement and getting that percentage of a return, I would be putting my investments somewhere else!
  22. It's a known issue. They had a bad batch of probes. Hopefully they get it resolved quickly. They were really good about replacing mine quickly.
  23. I will say it again, stream rehab isn't going to be worth the effort when there is adult mortality due to an alewife diet with Atlantics. Until Atlantics can evolve and overcome the Thiamine deficiency, rehabbing streams for them will be wasted funds. It will be good for the species that actually survive to adulthood and return like browns, steelhead, kings and coho.
  24. Irondequoit Creek is a trout stream year round. It's another option but for some reason its overlooked. Fish can get into Victor and there is tons of gravel and good water year round. The upper stretches in Victor don't have canal influence.
  25. Atlantics aren't returning because of adult mortality due to the thiamine issue. The feds don't supply us with a great product either. Fin damage on just about every Atlantic I have caught over the years. Niagara County offered to fund a new hatchery in Niagara county years back. The DEC killed that idea quickly.
×
×
  • Create New...