Can't go wrong with either. We went out of Mexico 2 weeks ago. Trolled to the plant and back and limited on cookie cutter browns in 20-40 fow, all spoons, anything green. This past Saturday launched out of Oswego, trolled towards the plant 70-90 fow, 3 browns and 2 small kings. Browns on spoons and the 2 kings on flasher/fly set up. Fished the marks and adjusted riggers and dipseys to the depths we were marking fish. Two of the browns came on a 10 color flatlined behind the boat with a spoon. Again, anything green. Good luck!