Jump to content

GAMBLER

Professional
  • Posts

    9,951
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by GAMBLER

  1. Many theories on this too. Biggest fished killed before hitting the spawning grounds, and hatcheries are two theories I have heard.
  2. Natural reproduction = less fish to be raised = less money the DEC has to spend to have a great fishery. Making changes = spending more money....... We all know this state cares more about downstate give aways before upstate outdoor recreation.
  3. This year, I didn't see any boxes full of giant kings........ Most barely broke 20lbs for the tournaments. Take the Sandy Creek shootout results. Not one team out of the 40+or- teams weighed in a 5 fish box over 100lbs. That's not even a 20lb average. only a couple teams topped 90lbs......
  4. There have been tournaments before the issue started. There was more pressure on the king population in the 80's. I wonder when the survival rate of naturally reproduced kings started to increase? I'd be willing to bet it is around the time size started to decline.
  5. Some but, they are managed for the lake. Without coolers being filled, alewife populations wouldn't be kept in check. The stocking numbers are set expecting a certain amount being taken out of the system. The salmon creel limit is the same in the lake as it is in the river at 3. They are spread out in TRILLIONS of gallons of water and they make a choice to eat a lure on the lake. They aren't stuffed into shallow narrow runs and easy pickings for lifters and snaggers,,,,, Low water years, the biggest kings get ripped out long before hitting the upper parts of the Salmon River. A true 4 year old king has a better chance getting roped on a tributary than it has being put in a cooler on the lake (unless it spawns on the Garnaska). My point is, they are managed for the lake. IF that is true, manage them for the lake. Steelhead are managed for the tribs and restrictions were put on the creel limit and minimum size in the lake. Do we have size and creel restrictions for kings on the tributary with the biggest production of wild fish in NY? Should we? If we depend on natural reproduction to keep the salmon fishery managed for the lake going, we should. If it's a trib that doesn't support natural reproduction ie Genessee River, Sandy, Oak Orchard,ect, go ahead and leave it at 3.
  6. It completely makes sense. The Garnaska has a natural reproducing population of kings and the tributary is closed to fishing for the majority of the spawn. This would allow the biggest to reproduce without being yanked out before being able to spawn. A lot of the big kings caught on the lake are caught on the North shore. Hmmm. If the lake is truly managed for the lake and we depend on natural reproduction more and more, how come kings are allowed to be yanked off their spawning beds and roped on South Shore tributaries that support natural reproduction? I know, I know, the Salmon River salmon run supports the local economy. But managing for the lake should mean managing for the lake........
  7. The baitfish population has been way higher the past couple of years compared to 10-15 years ago. Fish were bigger back then with less bait.
  8. I received the actual number of Atlantics stocked since 1983 from Mr. Legard from the DEC. The DEC has stocked over 100,000 Atlantics 25 times from 1983-2025. They have exceeded 150,000 5 times and 200,000 2 times. Here is the list provided by the DEC.
  9. In the past, they didn't want to bring in new genetics because they didn't want to mess with the current strain that has adapted to naturally reproducing in Lake Ontario. They could do Triploid salmon. They are sterile so they wouldn't mess with the genetics. Stock a percentage of the kings stocked as triploids. We could have numbers of kings AND some giants lingering around. We were told for years that the salmon size was down due to the bait biomass being smaller. The last couple of years, the biomass has been way up. By the logic of what we have been told for years, we should have giant kings again. I'm with you 100%. Something needs to be done.
  10. Good luck this season Rob!
  11. Good stuff Manny!
  12. Saturday evening out of Sandy, my buddy had a scary situation happen. They were trolling kings in 100' and saw a large cruiser heading directly at them. The boat was closing fast and they barely got out of the way in time. The boat took his leadcore and a diver rod for a ride. The wake almost swamped his boat. The driver was slumped over the wheel! He called 911 and reported the incident. Thank god he got out of the way in time! This just goes to show how important it is to have a proper look out while trolling!
  13. Would the Atlantics stocked in Lake Ontario have the instincts to return to Salt? I doubt it seeing that they are a different strain. Anything is possible. but there are a lot of obstacles in their way to make the voyage.
  14. Dave, Isn't there room at the Powder Mill Hatchery now that they will not be stocking browns in Irondequoit creek from the Hatchery?
  15. Dave, We agree!!!! Lol.
  16. Mmmmm Backstrap! Can't wait!
  17. The little amount of trout stocked from Powder Mill could be picked up at one of the other hatcheries. Again, I'm not saying to raise all the allotment of Atlantic's at Powder Mill. Raise some of the Atlantics you would be stocking at Powder Mill. This way they would imprint on the creek and return. Letting the fish decide to return when you are trying to restore a native species is not a great way to have success. Almost as dumb of a decision to boil Atlantics in a salmon farm in the lake.... If the project is to restore Atlantic populations, you have to give them the best chance to survive and naturally reproduce. To naturally reproduce, you have to get them to return to a tributary that can support it. If that is not the way the program is going to be ran, it should change to just a stocking program and dump them anywhere and move on. Putting money and resources into a project and not give the species the best chance at succeeding is a waste of time and resources.
  18. Does it count if it is a road kill doe? All joking aside, you know someone is going to do it.
  19. Tim, I'm talking about raising the Atlantics just for Irondequoit Creek at Powder Mill. Even the DEC is admitting Sandy isn't a good option. Dave mentioned it in his one post. Put Sandy to bed It's not going to work. I wish it was a viable option but it's not. If the program is about restoring a native species, Fish Farms will not work. Imprinting is important if you want the Atlantics to return home to a fertile trib to have a better chance at survival. Dumping them in the lake, they will roam and try to spawn anywhere. Why have Atlantics return to the Sandy, Genny, Oak, 18 mile ect. that are non-fertile tribs? Raising some Atlantics in a Hatchery on Irondequoit Creek will help imprinting for those fish. Seeing that Atlantics need to stay in the hatchery for the first year of their life, how well would they do in the summer when the lake temp is in the mid to upper 70's? Boiled Atlantic salmon anyone?
  20. Check with Brian at Rochester Reel Repair
  21. Now you are talking. That would save me hitting them with the fish bat!
  22. Powder mill has water. It has raceways. Plenty of room to raise the small amount of Atlantics to cover the stocking on the creek. It would take contracting out the hatchery and possibly staffing it. Raising them in the lake, they will not imprint on a trib. If they don’t imprint on a fertile trib, they could spawn anywhere. Chances of picking a trib that would support natural reproduction would be slim. That would be even worse than stocking them in the Oak and Sandy.
  23. That is bullsh*t. I would fill a doe tag early just to get my second buck tag but knowing that, I will not now. If I killed a doe in September, I would have more time to take more doe during the season.
×
×
  • Create New...