Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Are they totally gone from the lake?   I have not been up this summer due to boat owners problems, but what happened to them?     And what is happening to this web site?    Getting loanly here......jk

Posted

Alex Koeberle (PhD student), Suresh Sethi, Lars Rudstam, Evan Cooch, and Brad Hammers (NYSDEC), (Funded by NYSDEC) 

Cisco (Coregonus artedi) constituted the historical prey fish (mid-trophic) population in Keuka Lake. Yet, by the mid-1990s, the Cisco population was considered extirpated by lake managers with introduced Alewife and Rainbow Smelt among the most important drivers of their extirpation. While Rainbow Smelt gillnet catches declined in lake-wide surveys since the 2000s, managers observed a crash in Alewife catches after 2015. Despite these declines in prey fish, Keuka Lake supports an abundant, wild-reproducing Lake Trout population and popular sport fishery among anglers. This prompted NYSDEC to implement ongoing Cisco reintroductions to stabilize Keuka Lake’s mid trophic fish assemblage and improve recovery of the lake ecosystem. In 2025, we completed a population viability analysis to evaluate the likelihood of re-establishing a native Cisco population to Keuka Lake (Can J Fish Aquat Sci). We applied in situ estimates of juvenile fish survival from an acoustic telemetry study and in situ adult mortality rates estimated from a long-term catch dataset prior to their extirpation. We found that recovery is unlikely given two demographic processes: 1) high mortality of stocked juvenile fish upon release, and 2) high wild mortality in current lake conditions. Insights from these lake-specific datasets proved valuable for accurately assessing restoration success. This research provides guidance for fisheries conservation in Keuka Lake as well as comparable lakes throughout New York State.

Posted

So you are saying that they are totally gone so why not just take the millions of alewifes from Seneca & put some in here 

Posted
2 hours ago, Trouthunter said:

So you are saying that they are totally gone so why not just take the millions of alewifes from Seneca & put some in here 

I'm not saying anything. I just copied a bit of a Cornell study that answered the question. There used to be very many alewives (also known as mooneyes) in Keuka lake . They actually destroyed the cisco population. But a few years ago that alewife population collapsed and the lake trout population dropped very much. The DEC tried to improve the fishery by reintroducing ciscos , but it is a very tricky business that so far is not very succesfull.

Posted

The few Cisco's they stocked probably didn't make it 24 hours.  The numbers of starving lake trout in that lake is staggering.  

Posted (edited)

In addition to the Cisco and Alewife loss from the lake - ice fishing for the past several years has turned up an additional problem in the predator/prey relationship. The existing (often skinny) Lake Trout have been feasting in the shallows on tiny perch and sunfish; probably out of desperation. I have seen it firsthand with lakers spitting up these small fish still alive on the ice when brought out of the hole. I have seen it repeatedly so it is not a "one off" event. Long term this problem is affecting the fishery in multiple ways and not good ones.

Edited by Sk8man
Posted
1 hour ago, Sk8man said:

In addition to the Cisco and Alewife loss from the lake - ice fishing for the past several years has turned up an additional problem in the predator/prey relationship. The existing (often skinny) Lake Trout have been feasting in the shallows on tiny perch and sunfish; probably out of desperation. I have seen it firsthand with lakers spitting up these small fish still alive on the ice when brought out of the hole. I have seen it repeatedly so it is not a "one off" event. Long term this problem is affecting the fishery in multiple ways and not good ones.

With gobies being confirmed in Keuka, it might actually be a savior.  It will be interesting to see how they fishery changes.  The lakers might plump up pretty fast.  

Posted

Interesting Brian....wonder how they got in there. Isn't like the Cayuga/Seneca situation where they had a route up the canal system.

Posted (edited)

I wonder what killed the alewifes. Is there a connection between the gobi arrival and the mooneye demise? Or is some agricultural innovation responsible?

Somebody must have actively put the gobis in there, there is no way for them to make it up from Dresden.

Edited by rolmops
Posted
1 hour ago, rolmops said:

 

Somebody must have actively put the gobis in there, there is no way for them to make it up from Dresden.

 

 "bait bucket biologist" work at it's finest....

  • Haha 1
Posted
On 11/10/2026 at 1:54 PM, rolmops said:

I wonder what killed the alewifes. Is there a connection between the gobi arrival and the mooneye demise? Or is some agricultural innovation responsible?

Somebody must have actively put the gobis in there, there is no way for them to make it up from Dresden.

The extreme winters of 2014 and 2015 and lake trout over population killed off the alewife population.  Gobies came after the alewife wipeout.

Posted

We ice fished the bluffs those years and we did good or even great.   It was  a weird feeling walking all the way out there but there was over 12 inches of ice, maybe even 15 inches, that certainly must have had some effect on the population of the fish.....jk

Posted

 The gobies were put there no doubt.. Most likely by a local that wanted to establish a forage base for the lakers.. Anyone familiar with gobies knows you can get hundreds of them in no time at some  spots in Cayuga... They might give the lakers some forage in time, but they are voracious egg eaters, and will decimate spawning beds of Rock Bass, all species of Sunfish and SM and LM bass.. Many fishermen have NO idea how badly they have impacted the warm water fisheries in Cayuga.. The downrigger fishermen don't see it as the Gobies don't effect stocked trout much.. In fact Lakers love to eat them.. However, guys that fish near shore areas that are rocky have seen the devastation... I  no longer fish some areas in Cayuga  I fished for years as there is nothing to catch any longer except the damn Gobies.. They cause less problem in sandy or mud bottoms, as they seem to need rocks to proliferate.. Please don't think the Lakers in Keuka will keep Gobies "under control".. Cayuga has Lakers/Pike/SMB/LMB/Rock Bass/Crappies/Yellow Perch/even a few Walleyes and White perch all of whom will eat Gobies, yet they are so prolific they still  produced  a severe infestation... We'll see what happens, but Gobies seem able to out breed  any amount of predation.. Yes Keuka Laker Trout might get bigger and fatter,  but if everything else becomes scarce in the coming years was it worth it?.. The "stocker" whoever he is,  may have done irreparable  damage to this lake.. time will tell....

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...